|
CorrectCare
The
Graying of America’s Prisons
Related Stories
• Seeking
Solutions in Florida
• Elder
Care Busting Your Budget? Do the Math... Then Lobby for More |
|
The
Report
Correctional
Health Care: Addressing the Needs of Elderly,
Chronically Ill, and Terminally Ill Inmates
According to the National Institute of Corrections, which
commissioned this report, it is meant to “help prison
administrators explore options” for managing aging and infirm
inmates. Described as exploratory in nature, the report reviews
recent literature, describes promising approaches taken by
systems in six states and discusses “how agencies are meeting
related operational, programmatic, and health care delivery
challenges.”
The project was managed by the Criminal Justice Institute, a
national consulting firm headquartered in Middletown, CT. The
research and report writing were conducted by four expert
consultants: B. Jaye Anno, Camelia Graham, James E. Lawrence and
Ronald Shansky.
To view the report online (as a PDF document), visit www.nicic.org/Library/018735.
To obtain a free hard copy, fill out the online document request
form at that site, or call (800) 877-1461.
|
Corrections
Copes With Care for the Aged
By Jaime Shimkus
You’re only as old as you feel? That
timeworn adage certainly holds true for the 50-year-old inmate
who, body wracked by years of hard living and neglect of health
care, now attends clinics for diabetes and hypertension and can
barely move when his angina flares up. If he lives in Florida,
the state department of corrections defines him as
“elderly,” and that’s exactly how he feels.
And he’s not alone. The statistics are
sobering. On January 1, 2001, state and federal prisons housed
113,358 inmates age 50 or older, a 173% jump from 41,586 such
inmates in 1992. And the proportion of these older inmates has
risen, to 7.9% of the overall prison population in 2001 compared
to 5.7% in 1992.
These figures come from a recent report, Correctional
Health Care: Addressing the Needs of Elderly, Chronically Ill,
and Terminally Ill Inmates, commissioned by the National
Institute of Corrections and prepared by the Criminal Justice
Institute. (See box at right to learn how to obtain the report.)
Given the national demographic, crime and
sentencing trends that have contributed to the increase in
elderly prison inmates, their numbers likely will continue to
rise. Inevitably, this poses great challenges for correctional
systems, not only in determining what services to provide and
how, but also how to pay for them.
Accelerated Aging
Who qualifies as elderly? While definitions vary among
correctional institutions, a CJI study in 2001 found that, among
the 22 state agencies (of 49 responding) that had a working
definition of the term, the average first qualifying age was 55.
Some states used degree of disability in their definitions
rather than chronological age. The NIC report also points out
that the elderly population overlaps with two other categories
of special needs patients—chronically ill and terminally
ill—that also require enhanced services.
Whatever the definition, the transformation
to “elderly” is accelerated among prison inmates compared to
the general population. According to the NIC report, this faster
physiological aging adds 11.5 years, on average, to inmates’
chronological ages after age 50.
Factors behind this phenomenon include the
stress that new inmates experience as they try to survive
incarceration, avoid confrontation with inmates and staff, and
cope with financial pressures related to imprisonment;
withdrawal from substance abuse; lifelong histories of high-risk
behaviors; and inadequate health care before incarceration.
For those who have lived behind bars
awhile, add to that list debilitating stresses related to
reduced human interaction, lack of privacy, loss of self-esteem,
fear of dying in prison, and even fear of being released from
prison.
The most common signs of health
deterioration among inmates over age 50 include higher rates of
incontinence, sensory impairment, impaired flexibility,
respiratory illness, cardiovascular disease and cancer,
according to studies cited by the NIC report. As in the free
world, the most common chronic diseases are arthritis, high
blood pressure, ulcers, prostate problems and heart disease,
though these are more concentrated in correctional settings.
Of course, older inmates also experience
typical age-related problems: cognitive impairment, reduced
vision and hearing, muscle mass loss, incontinence, dietary
intolerance and general vulnerability, and, related to the
above, collateral emotional and mental health problems.
Not surprisingly, per capita costs of
incarcerating elderly inmates have soared, according to the NIC
report, to an average of $60,000 or $70,000 per year compared to
about $27,000 per inmate in general population. Looking at
health care alone, overall spending increased by 27% from 1997
to 2001.
Complex Challenges
So the challenge for prison systems is multifaceted. They
must:
• Assess how best to house and manage these special needs
inmates (e.g., mainstreaming vs. new construction or remodeling
of special units)
• Provide special accommodations, facilities and programs
(e.g., aids to geriatric living)
• Weigh epidemiological considerations, given this
population’s vulnerability to contagion
• Strive to contain costs
• Train medical and correctional staff to identify and respond
to the needs of this population
• Employ the most appropriate and effective functional
assessment tools. This, the NIC report says, is the key to
addressing all of the challenges above, since it makes clear
exactly what accommodations and services will be required.
Functional Assessment
Early and accurate identification of the complex needs of
elderly inmates is so important that the authors of the NIC
report devote a full chapter to it. As with any newly admission,
prison health care staff must perform an intake history or
screening exam and when they identify urgent needs, should refer
the inmate for assessment or treatment. In all cases a complete
medical history and physical exam should occur within seven
days. (See NCCHC’s Standards for Health Services
Section E, Inmate Care and Treatment, for the requirements for
accredited prisons.)
However, pitfalls in this process do
arise—for example, the inmate may not disclose health
information if the setting does not appear to ensure
confidentiality—and can result in a treatment plan that fails
to address an inmate’s special needs.
Also, prison classification and screening
instruments in use generally weren’t designed with the needs
of elderly inmates in mind, say the authors of the NIC report.
To prevent negative health outcomes for the inmate—and to
avoid serious liability for the prison—the report outlines two
strategies that should be considered. In one, the physician
lists individual inmates’ specific needs to enable appropriate
classification and placement. In the other, a detailed coding
system is used to aid decision making.
Even when assessment and placement are done
appropriately, problems may arise when a special needs inmate is
transferred to another institution. For example, delays may
occur when the second prison needs to reorder necessary medical
equipment or supplies. A system for tracking inmates with
special needs will help to prevent such problems.
Programs, Housing and Treatment
Since the elderly and chronically ill often need ongoing
care for multiple conditions, it is important that they be
housed in facilities that offer a full range of health services,
the NIC report authors advise. These include access to health
staff 24/7, specialty medical services and assistance with
activities of daily living. In addition, adaptive devices such
as walkers, hearing aids, extra blankets, etc., are likely to be
needed.
Housing arrangements should be based on
need, not age. Clearly, those with serious debilities would be
candidates for a nursing home setting or even an infirmary.
Older inmates in good health can live in general population,
though the NIC report cautions that facilities designed for
physically active people may be problematic architecturally.
Less tangible difficulties arise, too: Older inmates may not fit
in well with younger, aggressive inmates and may even be
victimized. Therefore, separate units that provide a more
sheltered environment and accommodations such as ramps and hand
rails may be worth considering.
Old age need not mean a continual downward
spiral. The NIC report notes that programming should strive to
help elderly inmates stay physically active and mentally alert,
for example, through self-help programs. This will lessen the
inevitable difficulties they’ll face if and when they are
released to the community.
—
About the author: Jaime Shimkus is NCCHC’s publications editor.
Related Stories
• Seeking Solutions in Florida
• Elder Care Busting Your Budget? Do the Math...Then Lobby for
More
[These articles first appeared in the
Summer 2004 issue of CorrectCare.]
|